| Back To Grand Theft Auto IV Reviews | Action/Adventure Reviews | New Reviews |
My Score: 6.4 out of 10.0
Graphics: 10.0
Sound Effects: 9.0
Interactivity: 7.0
Story: 5.0
Music: 1.0
Grand Theft Auto IV is a huge jump from its predecessors. The Xbox 360 makes good use of its graphical performance and many control related functions. This time you play as Nico Bellic, a european foriegner who is convinced by his cousin Roman that American life is like paradise and decides to set sail for Liberty City, where Roman has a taxi cab business. When Nico arrives, however, he discovers that America is not all what Roman has said it is. Quickly, Nico is forced into situations where he must take his military background and experience to the streets to survive in dangerous situations.
I will probably be blacklisted for my assessment of such a popular gaming franchise and series that gave rise to Grand Theft Auto IV, but I don't care. I'm going to tell it how it is. I don't subscribe to many conspiracy theories concerning brain washing via media sources or entertainment and I don't believe I am going to start now. I will, however, chalk up the shortfalls I've discovered in GTA IV to pure laziness or temptation of Rockstar Games' designers to cater to a very immoral worldview. I won't delve deeper into this and debate why I think this game presents an unbalanced view, but rather point out to you the shortcomings that my fellow reviewers did not see.
Before I do that, however, I will give GTA IV the credit it is due. First, the graphics are superb; the Xbox 360 is definitely pushed to its full capabilities. Unlike previous GTA games, IV has a true-to-life living, breathing Liberty City that really does feel alive. The A.I. is so advanced that it seems like these people actually have virtual lives that are lived out every moment. It is amazing to see them go about thier daily activities there like one would today in the real world. Looking around in all directions in Liberty City, takes your breath away. Its shear graphical perfection.
Aside from how beautiful environments and landscape are, the game's sound effects are amazing, especially in HD. Everything sounds very realistic down to the most distant ambient noise. Its easy to tell that much work was put into making GTA IV sound lived in and alive. There is no doubt that GTA IV has amazing sound quality infused into it.
Like most GTA games, GTA IV has you run around and do errands and missions to earn money, these usually involve driving someone or killing someone or sometimes both, so nothing is really new in that area, but there are some unique side-quests that aren't really story oriented, which I did find neat. You can hang out with friends and do activities such as bowling, playing pool, throwing darts, eating, going to a bar, and to a strip club. And to be sure, these things are more fun to do than the actually storyline missions themselves. For this reason, as I will explain later on, GTA IV fails in its presentation to remain video game entertainment and not something else. There are other activities that can be done by yourself aswell that don't require you to have someone with you. You can watch TV at your hideout and its pretty interesting some of the things you see, though mostly reality TV type stuff. You can shop for clothes like in San Andreas, though there is much more in the customization of your apparel. Another good aspect is there are jobs just about everywhere you look so its easy to make money without much trouble.
Combat in GTA IV is much improved from the previous games. You can use cover and firing rates are smooth. Also, you can fire behind cover without exposing yourself. And although I didn't master it, you can perform executions on your foes if you are close enough. Its probably not as realistic, but getting wanted levels is harder and escaping from the police is easier for some reason. I know in previous GTA games I found it frustrating to flee from the cops.
So, there are alot great things about GTAIV. But, as many great things as there about the game, I have found many shortfalls. They may not be issues to other reviewers, but I found they inhibited gameplay value and purpose. One of these is the protagonist. Nico Bellic seems like a guy with a reserved sense of morality when he is first introduced in the game. In fact, some of his initial conversation with Roman makes me believe that he actually wants nothing to do with criminals and the underground. However, he doesn't seem to mind taking jobs to steal, kill, and lie at almost every oppurtunity. Quickly, the game forces Nico to take on the role of an "any man" who is willing to do any job as long as he is getting paid. This includes backstabbing former allies. True, the game allows to make a choice in whom you backstab from time to time, but it is still forcing you to choose the lesser of two evils. All the while, Nico belly-aches and complains that he was "forced" into doing these things. So in the end, when America is not what Nico wants it to be, he succumbs to its pressures and proves that he is no better than any of the scum that he has put down. Why do we need to watch this story play out? Don't we see enough of this every day on television that we know what is going to happen in the end? I need not continue to delve into the storyline in GTA IV and tell you why Nico does the things he does. Its the same story that every GTA game has. Do a multitude of pointless missions so you can rise to the top and become powerful, then someone challenges you and you have to fight him. Its really starting to get boring.
Another huge shortcoming is GTA IV's fixation on sex and women. This is a huge problem facing video games these days. I'm not condemning games with existing sexual content in them, but rather our growing fixation on them. We want our video games to be realistic and have realistic life-like qualities, but having realistic sexual encounters, such as lap dances at a strip club and sex with prostitutes is affecting gamers in ways that go beyond the entertainment threshold of video gaming. Its appalling that designers would fixate so much on trying to make a lapdance in GTA IV as real as the real thing. The point I'm bringing up isn't unreasonable. If I made a game about croqueting and could make it as realistic as real croqueting, it would be much different than if you only had to croquet for 30 seconds. There are certain limits we should try uphold in good conduct.
Grand Theft Auto IV, like any game, had the oppurtunity to present something unique and interesting and it did in the sense of performance. The fact that it focused more on pleasing gamers who are anti-authority and sucked into an immoral world-view, is unfortunate. A thorough and focused story-line with more "cake" and less "frosting" I expect from Rockstar in its next installment of GTA. I'm sure they will make more.
| Back To Grand Theft Auto IV Reviews | Action/Adventure Reviews | New Reviews |
No comments:
Post a Comment